Antioxidant supplements have gained popularity, but research reveals conflicting evidence about their efficacy. Are these supplements worth the investment, or should we rely on whole foods for better health outcomes?
Dear food people,
Antioxidant supplements have been a topic of significant interest and debate in the scientific community. Despite the popularity of these supplements, research on their efficacy has produced mixed and sometimes conflicting findings.
While some studies show potential benefits for blended, lower-dose supplements, the overall scientific consensus does not strongly support the efficacy of antioxidant supplements for disease prevention or treatment. More research is needed to fully understand their effects. Experts generally recommend getting antioxidants from whole foods, which offer a combination of beneficial compounds working together synergistically.
The Safety and Efficacy of High-Dose Antioxidant Supplements
Several studies have raised concerns about the safety and efficacy of high-dose antioxidant supplements. Notably, a 2007 study published in JAMA concluded that supplements containing beta-carotene, vitamin A, and vitamin E might increase mortality rates, while vitamin C showed no impact on reducing mortality. However, some experts criticised the 2007 JAMA meta-analysis, suggesting it was flawed and excluded important studies that might have offered different results. The director of the Linus Pauling Institute notably referred to it as a "flawed analysis of flawed data."
Additionally, other studies such as the Finnish ATBC and CARET trials in the 1980s found that high-dose beta-carotene and vitamin A supplements did not reduce cancer incidence as initially hoped.
Despite these findings, the overall evidence remains inconclusive. The Harvard School of Public Health has stated that current studies generally do not provide strong evidence that antioxidant supplements have a substantial impact on disease prevention. Supporting this, a Stanford study comparing antioxidant-rich foods to supplement pills found no detectable decreases in inflammatory markers after eight weeks.
Cancer Prevention and Antioxidant Supplements
The scientific consensus, based on multiple large randomised, placebo-controlled clinical trials, does not support the idea that antioxidant supplements can prevent cancer. Nine randomised controlled trials of dietary antioxidant supplements for cancer prevention failed to provide evidence of their benefits. Furthermore, a systematic review by the United States Preventive Services Task Force found no clear evidence of benefit in preventing cancer from vitamin and mineral supplements.
Some studies have even found potential harm. For instance, the Alpha-Tocopherol, Beta Carotene Cancer Prevention Study observed a higher incidence of lung cancer among male smokers who received antioxidants compared to those who received a placebo. Similarly, the Selenium and Vitamin E Cancer Prevention Trial (SELECT) found no reduction in prostate cancer incidence with selenium and vitamin E supplements, and later analysis showed more prostate cancer cases among those who took vitamin E alone.
While some observational studies have suggested potential benefits, randomised controlled trials, which provide stronger evidence, have not confirmed these findings. It is possible that antioxidants from whole foods have different effects than purified supplements, but current evidence does not support using antioxidant supplements for cancer prevention.
HOW DO ANTIOXIDANTS IMPROVE SKIN HEALTH: TOPICAL VS. DIETARY APPROACHES?
Antioxidants play a significant role in skin health, and scientific studies have explored both their topical application and dietary intake. Understanding how these methods impact skin health can help you make informed decisions about your skincare routine and diet.
While these studies highlight the benefits of antioxidants for skin health, more long-term research is needed to fully validate these findings and determine their clinical implications. It's also important to note that the efficacy of antioxidants can vary based on the specific type, method of administration, and the particular skin condition being addressed. By understanding the advantages of both topical and dietary antioxidants, you can better tailor your skincare and dietary habits to promote optimal skin health.
Let’s not forget that an average adult has approximately 21 square feet of skin made up of about 300 million skin cells. Topical application appears to be more effective for targeted skin benefits, while oral consumption through a healthy diet provides broader health benefits that can improve overall skin health wherever repairs are required.
Topical Application of Antioxidants
Research indicates that the topical application of antioxidants, such as vitamin C, can improve the appearance of wrinkles and protect the skin from UV damage when used with sunscreen. Vitamin C is also effective in reducing the visibility of dark spots. Similarly, vitamin E, when included in moisturisers, offers skin benefits by promoting hydration and protection. Topical antioxidants can be directly applied to the skin, allowing for targeted delivery and higher concentrations to reach the skin.
Dietary Intake of Antioxidants
Dietary intake of antioxidants also shows promising results for skin health. A study published in the Nutrients journal found that diets rich in antioxidants were linked to a better quality of life for young women with acne vulgaris. Specifically, a higher Dietary Antioxidant Quality Index (DAQI) score was associated with a 30-33% reduction in acne risk and an improvement in quality of life. Additionally, dietary antioxidants, particularly vitamins A, C, and E, have demonstrated chemopreventive effects against skin cancer.
While fewer controlled studies show significant effects on skin, dietary antioxidants from fruits and vegetables benefit overall health and skin, potentially preventing photo-aging through compounds like polyphenols in green tea and caffeine.
Comparing Topical and Dietary Antioxidants
Both topical and oral antioxidant supplementation have shown efficacy in reducing sunburns, depigmentation, and photoaging. However, consuming a diet rich in antioxidants might be one of the most effective ways to enhance skin health from the inside out. The synergistic interactions between different antioxidants in whole foods appear to be crucial for their health-promoting effects on the skin. Topical antioxidants are generally considered more effective for skin-specific benefits, whereas oral antioxidants may offer broader health benefits that indirectly improve skin health.
Combining Topical and Dietary Approaches
Some studies suggest that combining topical and oral antioxidants may yield the best results for skin health. For instance, research has demonstrated that previous treatment with antioxidants can prevent oxidation in human skin caused by solar radiation. This approach could involve both topical and dietary interventions, providing a comprehensive strategy for maintaining healthy skin. Dermatologists recommend topically applied antioxidants for a healthy skin glow but acknowledge that a combination of both methods may provide the best overall results.
While topical application of antioxidants can be beneficial as a localised treatment, consuming a diet rich in antioxidants is considered one of the best ways to improve overall skin health from the inside out. Here’s how dietary antioxidants can promote better skin health:
Protection against free radical damage: Antioxidants help protect skin cells from damage caused by free radicals, which can lead to premature aging and other skin problems.
Collagen production: Some antioxidants, like vitamin C, help the body produce collagen, which is essential for maintaining skin structure and elasticity.
Sun damage protection: Antioxidants like beta-carotene, lycopene, and vitamins C and E can help protect skin from UV damage when consumed alongside sunscreen use.
Improved skin appearance: Antioxidant-rich diets have been associated with softer skin, reduced moisture loss, and protection of skin cells from sun damage.
Wrinkle reduction: Some studies suggest that vitamin C applied topically may help improve the appearance of wrinkles.
Dark spot reduction: Vitamin C may help make dark spots on the skin less visible.
Wound healing: Iron, an antioxidant mineral, may help wounds heal faster.
Anti-inflammatory effects: Many antioxidants have anti-inflammatory properties that can benefit skin health.
Intracellular signalling: Antioxidants can affect intracellular signalling pathways, which may contribute to maintaining healthy skin.
Overall skin quality: A diet rich in antioxidants from fruits, vegetables, nuts, whole grains, and fatty fish promotes healthy skin in general.
HOW DO DIGESTIVE ENZYMES ENHANCE THE ABSORPTION OF VITAL VITAMINS?
Digestive enzymes are essential for the breakdown of food and the absorption of vital vitamins such as A, C, and E. These enzymes facilitate the conversion of complex nutrients into forms that can be easily absorbed by the body, enhancing the bioavailability of antioxidants that support skin health. Proper enzyme function, along with other factors such as diet composition and individual health conditions, is crucial for maximising the nutritional benefits of vitamins.
General Effects of Digestive Enzymes
Digestive enzymes aid in breaking down complex nutrients into smaller, more bioavailable components, allowing the body to absorb vitamins and other nutrients more effectively. This improved nutrient absorption and bioavailability are particularly important for vitamins A, C, and E, which are crucial for skin health. Moreover, various factors such as food processing, the presence of antagonists, alcohol consumption, diseases, and certain drugs can influence the activity of digestive enzymes, thereby affecting the absorption and utilisation of vitamins.
It is important to note that while digestive enzymes play a significant role in nutrient absorption, other factors such as the food matrix, the presence of dietary fats, and individual physiological conditions also significantly impact the bioavailability of these vitamins. For instance, the food matrix can affect how nutrients are released during digestion, while dietary fats can enhance the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins like vitamin A.
Vitamin A
For vitamin A, the role of digestive enzymes is particularly critical. Pancreatic enzymes, specifically pancreatic triglyceride lipase, are essential for hydrolysing dietary retinyl esters, which are the primary form of preformed vitamin A found in foods. This hydrolysis occurs in the intestine, where the retinyl esters are converted into unesterified retinol, a form that can be readily absorbed by intestinal cells. Additionally, the intestinal brush border enzyme phospholipase B aids in the hydrolysis of retinyl esters, further facilitating the absorption process.
Vitamins C and E
Although specific digestive enzymes for vitamins C and E are not detailed in the available research, it is well established that digestive enzymes, in general, assist in breaking down food, thereby improving the absorption of these vital antioxidants. The process of digestion stimulates the secretion of enzymes, which enhances the absorption of nutrients, including vitamins C and E. Proper enzyme function ensures that the body can extract and utilise these antioxidants from the food consumed, which is essential for maintaining healthy skin.
Influence of Nutrient Interactions
The presence of other nutrients in food can significantly impact the bioavailability of vitamins A, C, and E. For fat-soluble vitamins like A and E, dietary fats are crucial for absorption. The presence of fats in a meal stimulates the secretion of pancreatic enzymes and bile acids, which are necessary for hydrolysing and absorbing these vitamins. For vitamin A specifically, the intake of dietary fats enhances the hydrolysis of retinyl esters by pancreatic enzymes and bile acids.
However, there are also competing nutrients that can affect vitamin absorption. For instance, carotenoids (precursors to vitamin A) and vitamin E may compete for absorption, with high doses of either potentially reducing the bioavailability of the other. Additionally, the food matrix, which includes interactions with proteins, fibre, and fats, can influence the bioaccessibility and bioavailability of these vitamins. Food processing can further impact vitamin bioavailability by altering the food matrix.
Certain nutrients can enhance or inhibit vitamin absorption. For example, vitamin C can enhance the absorption of non-heme iron from plant sources, which indirectly affects overall nutrient absorption. Conversely, some nutrients or compounds can act as antagonists, reducing vitamin absorption or utilisation. Examples of nutrients and compounds that reduce vitamin absorption includes:
Phytates (Phytic Acid) are found in whole grains, seeds, nuts, and legumes. They can bind to minerals such as iron, zinc, and calcium, reducing their absorption. In oats, for example, it forms insoluble complexes that can reduce the bioavailability of these minerals. This antagonistic effect can indirectly impact the bioavailability of vitamins that depend on these minerals for their function.
Oxalates, present in foods like spinach, rhubarb, and beet greens, can bind to calcium and form insoluble complexes, reducing calcium absorption. This can affect the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins like vitamin D, which works synergistically with calcium.
Do Polyphenol-Rich Foods like Tea, Coffee, Berries, and Olive Oil Affect Nutrient Absorption?
Polyphenol-rich foods are known for their health benefits, but studies show that they can also affect the absorption of some vitamins and minerals. Here’s an exploration of specific foods and their interactions with vitamin absorption.
Tea
Especially black tea, contains high levels of polyphenols that can reduce the absorption of non-heme iron, which is iron from plant sources. Since vitamin C enhances iron absorption, the polyphenols in tea could indirectly affect the utilisation of vitamin C.
Coffee
Coffee contains high levels of polyphenols, particularly chlorogenic acids. While the direct impact on nutrient absorption isn’t well-documented, coffee is known to inhibit iron absorption.
Cocoa
Cocoa is celebrated for its rich polyphenol content and potential health benefits. However, consuming large amounts of cocoa polyphenols may interfere with the absorption of minerals such as iron and zinc, which are crucial for various bodily functions.
Berries
Berries are packed with polyphenols and vitamin C. Unlike other polyphenol-rich foods, there is no specific evidence suggesting that berries negatively impact vitamin absorption. On the contrary, the vitamin C in berries may actually enhance iron absorption.
Olive Oil
Olive oil is another polyphenol-rich food. Known for its numerous health benefits, there is no specific evidence indicating that it impacts nutrient absorption.
Balancing Polyphenol Consumption and Nutrient Absorption
While polyphenol-rich foods can potentially impact vitamin absorption, the effect is generally minimal within a balanced diet. The health benefits of these foods typically outweigh any minor reductions in vitamin absorption. However, to maximise nutrient absorption while still benefiting from polyphenols, consider the following tips:
Variety in Diet: Consume a diverse mix of foods to ensure a balanced intake of nutrients.
Timing of Consumption: Space out the consumption of high-polyphenol foods and iron-rich foods or supplements if iron absorption is a concern.
Whole Food Sources: Focus on obtaining nutrients from whole foods rather than relying heavily on supplements.
And hey, feel free to drop us a message at me@obsideonmedia.com if you've got something to say or a question to ask. Let's keep the conversation going and make food sustainability a part of our daily habits together.
Further Reading:
Absorption of Vitamin A and Carotenoids by the Enterocyte - NCBI https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3798921/
Antioxidant Supplements: What You Need To Know | NCCIH https://www.nccih.nih.gov/health/antioxidant-supplements-what-you-need-to-know
Antioxidants Accelerate the Growth and Invasiveness of Tumors in ... https://www.cancer.gov/news-events/cancer-currents-blog/2015/antioxidants-metastasis
Antioxidants and Cancer Prevention - NCI https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/diet/antioxidants-fact-sheet
Dietary Antioxidants - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/dietary-antioxidants
Evaluation of in-vivo model for vitamin A bioavailability from vitamin ... https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352044119_Evaluation_of_in-vivo_model_for_vitamin_A_bioavailability_from_vitamin_A_loaded_caseinate_complex
Evidence-Based Utility of Adjunct Antioxidant Supplementation for ... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10451863/
Potential Health Benefits of Dietary Antioxidants from Supplements ... https://med.stanford.edu/nutrition/research/completed-studies/dietary-antioxidants.html
Understanding the bioavailability of vitamins in food https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6363532/
The information provided in our articles is for educational and entertainment purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or another qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. The content on our website, including articles, is not meant to endorse or promote any specific medical treatments, products, or procedures. The information provided is based on general knowledge and research at the time of writing. Medical practices and knowledge are constantly evolving, and what may have been accurate at the time of publication may not be current or applicable today.